Asphalt vs. Metal Roof: A Head-to-Head Cost Comparison

Replacing your roof is one of the biggest investments you will make in your home. When the time comes, the biggest question homeowners in Elsinore and throughout Sevier County ask us is: “Should I stick with asphalt shingles, or is it time to upgrade to metal?”

There is no single “right” answer. The best choice depends on your budget, how long you plan to stay in your home, and your aesthetic preferences.

However, living in Central Utah means our roofs face unique challenges—heavy snow loads in winter, intense high-altitude UV rays in summer, and rapid freeze-thaw cycles in spring.

At Insight Roofing, we install both types of roofing systems. Here is an honest comparison of how they stack up against our local climate to help you decide.

The Contender: Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material in North America for a reason. They are reliable, affordable, and look good on almost any style of home.

The Pros:

• Cost-Effective: Asphalt has the lowest upfront cost of any reliable roofing material.
• Variety: Available in countless colors and styles, including architectural shingles that mimic slate or wood shake.
• Easy Repairs: If a severe windstorm blows off a few shingles, they are relatively easy and inexpensive to match and replace.

The Cons for Utah:

• Shorter Lifespan: While rated for 25-30 years, the intense Utah sun dries out the asphalt oils over time, making them brittle. A realistic lifespan here is often 20-25 years.
• Snow and Ice: Asphalt granules grip snow. While this provides some insulation, it can also contribute to heavy snow loads and ice dam formation if attic ventilation isn’t perfect.

The Challenger: Metal Roofing

Metal roofing has grown tremendously in popularity in recent years, moving beyond barns and commercial buildings to residential homes in Elsinore.

The Pros:

• Unmatched Durability: Metal roofs can last 40 to 70 years. It will likely be the last roof you ever buy.
• Snow Shedding: This is a major advantage in Sevier County. Snow slides right off metal roofs, preventing heavy, dangerous buildup and virtually eliminating ice dams.
• Energy Efficiency: Metal reflects the summer sun rather than absorbing it, which can lower cooling costs during our hot July and August days.
• Fire Resistance: Metal is non-combustible, offering peace of mind in wildfire-prone areas.

The Cons for Utah:

• Higher Upfront Cost: A quality metal roof is a significant initial investment, often costing 2-3 times more than an asphalt roof.
• Noise: Without proper insulation and underlayment, rain and hail can sound louder on a metal roof. (We ensure proper installation to mitigate this).

The Verdict: Which Should You Choose?

When trying to decide between the two for your Sevier County home, ask yourself these questions:

Choose Asphalt Shingles If:

• You have a tighter budget for the project right now.
• You plan on moving within the next 10–15 years.
• You prefer the traditional look of shingles and want an easy installation process.

Choose Metal Roofing If:

• This is your “forever home” and you want the lowest long-term cost of ownership.
• You are tired of worrying about heavy snow loads and ice dams every winter.
• You want maximum protection against wind, hail, and fire.

Still Undecided? Let’s Talk.

Both materials, when installed correctly by experienced professionals, will protect your home. At Insight Roofing, we can provide you with side-by-side quotes for both asphalt and metal so you can make an informed decision based on real numbers.

If you live in Elsinore or the surrounding areas, give us a call today to discuss your project.

---